Why High Performers Cheat — and Why They Can't Stop

There's a specific kind of person who shows up in relationship strategist Katarina Polonska's practice over and over. Successful. Driven. Accomplished by every external measure. And completely stuck in a relationship pattern they can't think their way out of.

They're CEOs, founders, senior partners. People who've built empires and can't figure out why they keep destroying their marriages. Or staying in ones that stopped working years ago. Or falling for someone who was never fully available.

In my conversation with Katarina on The Scarlet Edit, we dug into why this happens — not from a place of judgment, but from a place of actually understanding the wiring underneath it all.

The Fear of Being Bad Is Running the Show

Here's something Katarina sees constantly with her high-performing clients: they're terrified of being the bad guy. Not in a casual "I'd feel guilty" way. In a primal, identity-level way.

She traces it back to childhood. So many high performers were conditioned to earn love through achievement. Do more, be better, don't disappoint. That creates an adult who will do almost anything to avoid being seen as bad — including living a double life rather than having the hard conversation that might hurt someone.

The cruel irony? That fear of being bad becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. You're so afraid of being the villain that you avoid the honest conversation, start seeing someone else, and become the exact thing you were trying not to be.

Katarina put it plainly in our conversation — you are not inherently a bad person. You might have behaviors that don't align with your own integrity, but behaviors can be changed. Patterns can be changed. The identity of "I'm bad at my core" is what keeps the whole cycle spinning.

Why "Should I Stay or Go" Is the Wrong First Question

This is probably the most universally relatable part of what Katarina shared. The question she hears more than anything else — from people in marriages, in affairs, in situationships — is "how do I know when it's time to leave?"

Her answer surprised me in its simplicity: it's time to go when there's no more growth left. When you can honestly say you've examined your own role, shifted your own behaviors, taken full ownership of your side — and the relationship still isn't working.

The problem is most people skip straight to the exit without doing that work first. They're comparing their partner to someone else, or seeing everything through what Katarina calls "negative sentiment override" — where you've been unhappy so long that literally everything your partner does looks bad to you. That's not clarity. That's a wound talking.

And here's the kicker that stuck with me: for every divorce you have, the statistical likelihood of your next marriage also ending in divorce goes up. If you don't address the patterns driving the dysfunction, you'll just recreate them with a new person.

The 4% Problem — Why Most Affair Relationships Don't Survive

We talked about the statistic that only about 4% of affair relationships actually work out long-term. Katarina's take on why was fascinating — it's not because the two people are inherently a bad match. It's because most people don't know themselves well enough to make clear decisions from a grounded place.

In her experience, affairs are less about the other person and more about the needs they're fulfilling. Feeling desired. Feeling significant. Feeling interesting again. These are valid needs, but they're often coming from wounded places. And when the affair partner becomes the actual partner — when the excitement fades and the novelty wears off — there's sometimes nothing underneath it.

Her advice? Before making any major relationship decisions, take time alone. Let the hormones settle. Get clear on what needs are being met and whether you can start meeting them yourself. Only from that sovereign place can you actually see whether a connection is rooted in genuine compatibility or just emotional dependency.

Why 15 Years of Therapy Didn't Fix It

One of the boldest moments in our conversation was Katarina's take on traditional talk therapy. She spent 15 years in it herself — different therapists, committed effort — and it kept her going in circles.

Her argument isn't that therapy is useless. It's that talk therapy is great at building awareness of the problem but doesn't necessarily give you the tools to actually change the pattern. You keep coming back, keep telling the story, and sometimes you start identifying with it so deeply that it becomes who you are. "I'm the person who struggles in love" becomes a fixed identity rather than a pattern you can shift.

What changed things for her was learning how the subconscious mind actually works and getting practical tools to recondition those patterns — not just understand them. Her clients typically work with her for three to six months and then they're out. They have the tools. They don't need her on speed dial.

The Other Woman Deserves Compassion Too

This part of our conversation hit me personally. I asked Katarina what happens to the other woman when the person having the affair goes to a coach to "fix" things. Because I know my listeners — many of them are that person, and they're thinking "what about me?"

Katarina does something unorthodox: she sometimes works with everyone in the dynamic — the betrayer, the spouse, and the other person — all confidentially. Her perspective is that everyone in the situation has their own patterns, their own wounds, and their own blocks. Everyone deserves support.

She also named something I've talked about on this show before but never quite heard articulated this way: there's an inherent powerlessness in being the other woman. You're waiting for someone else's decision. You're on the sidelines of your own life. And that powerlessness? It's not just situational. It's usually a pattern that existed long before this relationship — and it'll follow you into the next one if you don't address it.

Her father is actually proof that it can work — he left his wife and has been with the other woman for 15 years, happily. But it's rare. And it only works when both people have done the inner work.

The Bottom Line

Every pattern in your relationships — the settling, the waiting, the staying too long, the leaving too fast — is running on subconscious programming. Until you address it at that level, you'll keep getting the same results with different people.

That's not a life sentence. It's an invitation. And honestly, it's the most empowering thing Katarina said in our entire conversation: you can change your patterns. You can change your outcomes. But you have to be willing to look at yourself first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do successful people cheat more often? High performers are often conditioned from childhood to equate achievement with love and approval. That same wiring creates an intense fear of being "bad" or disappointing others, which paradoxically makes it harder to have honest conversations in a marriage — and easier to justify a double life. Additionally, research suggests that the more money a man earns, the more likely he is to cheat, potentially driven by seeking internal validation through power over others.

How do you know when to leave a marriage? According to relationship strategist Katarina Polonska, the answer is when there's no more growth left — meaning you've genuinely examined your own role in the relationship, worked on your own patterns, and shifted your own behaviors first. If the relationship still isn't working after you've done that honest inner work, you can walk away knowing you left no stone unturned.

Why do people keep repeating the same relationship patterns? Our subconscious mind — which drives roughly 95 to 97% of our behavior — creates coherence between our internal beliefs and external reality. If you carry a deep belief that you're not good enough or that you'll be abandoned, your subconscious will steer you into situations that confirm those beliefs. This is why people often find themselves repeatedly in affairs, repeatedly being cheated on, or repeatedly choosing emotionally unavailable partners.

Can a relationship that started as an affair actually work? Statistically, only about 4% of affair relationships survive long-term. However, the low success rate isn't necessarily because the people are a bad match — it's because most people enter the new relationship driven by unmet emotional needs rather than genuine compatibility. When those needs eventually get met or the novelty fades, there's often nothing substantial underneath. The relationships that do work tend to involve both people doing significant inner work and choosing each other from a grounded, sovereign place.

Is traditional therapy effective for fixing relationship patterns? Talk therapy is valuable for building awareness and understanding the origins of your patterns. However, it often falls short in providing the practical tools needed to actually change those patterns at a behavioral level. Many people spend years in therapy gaining insight without experiencing real change, and in some cases, they begin to over-identify with their story of struggle. Approaches that combine awareness with practical behavioral change tools and real-world application tend to produce faster, more lasting results.

❤️‍🔥 Want to learn more about The Scarlet Edit? Start here.
📲 Subscribe to the show on Apple, Spotify or YouTube so you don’t miss an episode!
💌 Want more conversations like this? Sign up for the newsletter below.