Why Men Pull Away After Getting Close (What I Learned in Three Weeks)

Three weeks. That's how long I saw a guy in Scottsdale before I left for Greece, and for three weeks he did everything right. He asked me out after every date. He pursued me. His texts weren't "morning, sexy" nonsense, they were plans, because we actually saw each other. His actions backed up his words. Then one morning they stopped, and I got a front-row seat to a question a lot of women in their 40s are asking: why do men pull away after getting close?

When his actions matched his words, until they didn't

I let him lead, and I loved it. I'm happiest in my feminine, and being wanted by a man I actually wanted back felt good. There was no confusion. A few days before my flight I had him over for dinner. We cooked, we laughed, he was honest with me. He wasn't love-bombing, and that mattered to me. Everything felt intentional.

Then I stayed at his place, and the next morning his kid walked in and saw a strange woman in his dad's bed. The energy changed on the spot. I'm not a parent and I won't comment on anyone's parenting. I'll only say this: if I pulled up to someone's house at seven in the morning and there was clearly a woman's car in the driveway, I wouldn't have allowed my child to walk in without checking first. That's not how it went.

By the time he drove me to the airport, he showed up in sunglasses and never took them off. If a man can't look me in the eyes, there's a problem.

Why men pull away after getting close

He got exactly what he'd been chasing, a strong woman, who was ready for something real, just like he said he was, and the second real life bumped into it, he retreated. While I was in Greece I got the text I'd been waiting for. He said he's not good at letting people in, that the morning threw him off, that nothing had changed about how he felt and he missed me.

I responded honestly. I told him I didn't think he was acknowledging that this affected me too, and that going quiet on me had hurt my feelings. But I followed that up with a voicenote, so he could actually hear me speak, and shared my feelings and what I was ready for. What came back? Zero acknowledgement, aside from a reel of tigers in a sexual position. WHAT? A few days later… a surface-level text that didn't deserve a reply.

I feel like someone popped out his SD card and put in a new one. The man I spent three weeks with was gone.

How I knew I was ready for something real

I was disappointed. Three weeks isn't long and I know that. But the disappointment came with a surprise. I'm ready for something real.

Dating him, I caught myself wondering if I could build something with this guy. I pictured my friends meeting him. I thought about their husbands liking him. That's not nothing. The fact that I let myself imagine weaving someone into my life means I'm actually open to it. Now it's just a matter of time and the universe sending me the right person.

My non-negotiable is communication

The other thing I'm proud of is that my boundary held. Communication is the foundation for me. If a man can't communicate, nothing else matters, and I can say that out loud now without flinching.

An old version of me would have taken whatever I could get because I liked him. Not anymore. I like me more. I respect myself. When he couldn't meet me on the one thing I don't bend on, I let it go instead of making myself smaller to keep him around.

Back on the apps in Greece, and the height lie I left over

So, onward. I gave Hinge a whirl in Greece. I matched with a guy who wrote great English and talked about showing me local spots. I asked if he grew up speaking English and Greek. He said he'd made a point to learn English well.

In person, he looked older than his photos and was a lot shorter than his profile claimed. Height isn't something anyone can control, and I don't care about the number. I care about the lie. If you're 5'10", you're not six feet. If you're 5'11", you're not six feet. We are going to meet, so don't start a potential relationship lying about it.

He also barely spoke English. I'd had two glasses of wine and zero interest in a third while I repeated myself in words simple enough for him to follow. I texted my friend Katie, and she said exactly what I needed to hear: leave, you don't owe someone anything, especially someone who lied to you. Seconds after we sat down I said I needed the restroom, got up, left, and unmatched him before I made it back to my apartment.

Somebody will call that rude. The rude part was the lie that got him the date in the first place. I don't owe a stranger my whole evening.

Dating in your 40s: common questions

Why do men pull away after getting close?

Often it's because closeness starts to feel like pressure. A man chases hard to win you, then retreats once real feelings or real life show up, because staying would mean being vulnerable and consistent. It says more about his capacity than your worth. Watch whether his actions keep matching his words past the honeymoon window, not just at the start.

Is it rude to leave a bad date early?

No. You don't owe a stranger hours of your time to be polite, especially if they misrepresented themselves to get the date. A quick, honest exit is fair. Excusing yourself and leaving is enough, and you can unmatch afterward.

Is lying about height on dating apps a red flag?

Yes. Roughly half of daters exaggerate height, and you'll find out the second you meet in person. The inches aren't the issue. The willingness to lie before you've even said hello is. If someone opens with a lie you can measure, question what else they'll fudge.

How do you know you're ready to date again?

You catch yourself imagining someone in your actual life, meeting your friends, fitting your routine, and it feels exciting instead of scary. You hold your boundaries even when you really like the person. And you'd rather be on your own than shrink to keep someone who can't meet you where you are.

🕸️Waiting to be chosen? Download The Affair Edit.
🌱 Tired of performing? Get The Self-Worth Reset.
❤️‍🔥 Want to learn more about The Scarlet Edit? Start here.
🍒 Interested in working with me? Let’s chat.
📲 Subscribe to the show on Apple, Spotify or YouTube so you don’t miss an episode!
💌 Want more conversations like this? Sign up for the newsletter below.