Getting Back on Dating Apps in Your 40s When You've Been Single a While

For years, my answer to dating apps was a flat no. I've been single a while. I am independent, comfortable in my own company, and I've built a life I genuinely like. Every time the apps came up, I passed. I'd tried them before and never once enjoyed the experience, so why sign up for more of that?

This summer I changed my mind. Not because being alone stopped working for me, but because I actually do want someone in my life, and you can't want that and keep doing nothing about it.

Why getting back on dating apps in your 40s feels harder than it should

Nobody tells you this about being single a long time and being fine at it: it makes you really good at not dating. You get into a routine. You get used to your own company. You stop putting energy toward meeting anyone because you don't have to, and honestly, it's easier not to.

That comfort is a gift and a trap at the same time. I love my independence. I'm not going to apologize for enjoying my own life. But at some point I had to be honest that "I'm perfectly happy on my own" and "I'd like to share my life with someone" can both be true, and only one of them was getting any effort from me.

Getting back on the apps in your 40s means overriding years of a very convenient habit. That's the real challenge, not the swiping.

Dating again after being single starts with the energy you bring

I'm a big believer that energy changes outcomes. So this time, instead of downloading an app already braced for disappointment, I decided to go in for fun.

Maybe I'd meet someone cool. Maybe I'd make a new friend. Maybe I'd just laugh. I genuinely didn't know, and I decided that was fine. I wasn't there to audition anyone or to prove the apps were as bad as I remembered. I was there to have a good time and see what happened.

That reframe did more for me than any profile tip ever could. When you stop treating every match like a job interview and start treating it like an experiment you might enjoy, the whole thing gets lighter.

One date turned into three, and the third one was in Vegas

Once I got back out there, I went on a date in Scottsdale. Then I went on one in LA, where I've been spending the summer. That one turned into a second date, which turned into a third, and that third date happened to be in Las Vegas.

We spent the day bouncing between casinos and hotels to stay out of the 111-degree heat, had a great dinner, and then he brought up something I'd mentioned in passing earlier: that I love country music. He'd never been to Blake Shelton's Ole Red, said the people he'd been with before never wanted to go, and remembered that I'd like it. So we went.

There was a cover band. I knew every word to every song, so of course I sang along the entire time. And he liked watching me do it. That was the best part of the night for both of us.

I'll say this about dating again after being single a while: I'd forgotten how good it feels to sit across from someone and just laugh. Humor is wildly underrated. Laughing is good for the soul. Meeting someone who makes you laugh, and who lets you make them laugh right back, is not a small thing.

The part of midlife dating nobody warns you about

Here's where it gets complicated for me specifically. My whole thing is talking about my life. This podcast, this series, this is what I do. But the person I met didn't sign up for that. It's not his world.

So I've kept things vague on purpose, and I'll keep doing that. I can share what this experience is bringing up for me without turning someone else into content. That's a line I care about.

Whatever happens next, I'm grateful. It's a genuinely nice thing to have shared this stretch of time with someone I enjoy this much.

Every small decision compounds into the life you end up with

The thing I keep coming back to is decisions. We make dozens of tiny ones every day. Where to eat lunch. Whether to say yes to a last-minute trip. Whether to spend a whole month in a different city.

They all add up. They compound. You end up on a path that twists and turns in ways you couldn't have planned, and along the way you meet people you'd never have met otherwise. If I hadn't decided to come to LA when I did, this person would not be in my life right now. That's wild to think about.

Getting back on the apps was one of those decisions. So was going in with good energy instead of dread. So was saying yes to Vegas. None of them felt momentous in the moment. All of them added up to something good.

If you've been telling yourself you're too independent to date, or too settled in your own routine to bother, I get it. I was there. But comfort and possibility aren't the same thing, and you only get one of them by staying exactly where you are.

FAQ

Is it normal to feel too independent to date after being single a long time?

Yes. When you've been single a while and gotten comfortable on your own, not dating becomes a habit. Enjoying your independence doesn't mean you don't want a relationship. It just means dating takes intentional effort you're out of practice with.

How do you get back on dating apps in your 40s after a bad experience?

Go in with a different mindset than last time. Instead of bracing for disappointment, treat it as a low-stakes experiment where the goal is to have fun and meet interesting people. The energy you bring changes what you get back.

What's the hardest part of dating again in midlife?

For a lot of people it's overriding the comfort of a routine they actually like. For me, it's also figuring out how much of my life to share when the other person didn't sign up to be public. Both take some real honesty with yourself.

Can you be independent and still want a relationship?

Absolutely. Being perfectly happy on your own and wanting to share your life with someone can both be true at once. Wanting companionship doesn't cancel out your independence.

🕸️Waiting to be chosen? Download The Affair Edit.
🌱 Tired of performing? Get The Self-Worth Reset.
❤️‍🔥 Want to learn more about The Scarlet Edit? Start here.
🍒 Interested in working with me? Let’s chat.
📲 Subscribe to the show on Apple, Spotify or YouTube so you don’t miss an episode!
💌 Want more conversations like this? Sign up for the newsletter below.