Getting Back Into Dating in Midlife: What Two Years Off Taught Me

I've been out of the dating game for a couple of years. Not because anything went wrong. I got comfortable. I built a life I love, I got independent in a way that felt good, and dating just wasn't the thing I was reaching for. So when I got back on the apps this summer, I figured it would feel like riding a bike. It did not.

Getting back into dating after years off stirs up more than you expect

Here's what nobody warns you about getting back into dating in midlife. When you've spent a couple of years happily minding your own business, factoring another person in feels strange. You meet someone, you feel a little spark, and your first reaction isn't butterflies. It's "whoa, whoa, whoa, what is all of this?"

I met a guy on Hinge while I was in LA. Two dates there, one in Vegas, and every single time was genuinely fun. He's British, I'm American, and somewhere in the slang and the sarcasm a few things didn't land the way they were meant to. That's dating. That's two people figuring out whether the way they talk to each other actually works.

What I noticed most wasn't about him. It was about me. The growth I've done over the last couple of years gave me boundaries and expectations I didn't have before. Knowing what I need is one thing. Voicing it to someone I just met is a whole different skill, and I was rusty at it.

Dating without attaching to the outcome

A guy on the app asked me the other day, "What are you here for?" It's a fair question and also an impossible one, because I don't know. You don't know who you're going to meet or how you'll feel when you do.

There's a dating coach I follow named Erika, and she talks about NATO, not attached to outcome. I'm bought in. When you walk into a date already wondering if this person is a boyfriend or a husband, you spend the whole time analyzing them through that lens. You miss the actual person across from you. You miss the good conversation, and you miss the bad one too.

So my answer now is simple. I'm here to meet people. Maybe I get a friend. Maybe I get a fling. Maybe I get love. Taking the pressure off makes the whole thing lighter, and lighter is where I want to be right now.

The apps are a numbers game, even when they're people

I hate saying it, because we're talking about human beings with feelings. But the apps are a numbers game. You match, you trade a few messages, and then someone vanishes and you're left staring at a conversation that just disappeared. Wait, I thought I had four matches. Now I have three. Which one left?

I've done it to men too, so I'm not pretending I'm above it. What I wish existed is a way to unmatch and still leave a note. Something like, "I think we're at different places in life, wishing you the best." Instead the whole thing evaporates and nobody gets closure.

And then there's the stuff that only happens once you put yourself out on the internet. I matched with a man, we started texting, and he said my voice sounded familiar. His algorithm had been feeding him my videos, going back to the 92 days last fall when I posted every day trying to get Dear Media's attention and get settled in a new city. He'd seen dozens of them. Then he asked me to dinner anyway. We had a great time.

The story your brain writes about a match before you meet them

This is the part I think about constantly. You match with someone, and before you've met them, your brain builds a whole person out of a few photos and a bio. Then you meet the real one and you might be let down, not because they did anything wrong, but because they can't live up to a version they never agreed to be.

It happens most with the physical stuff. I met a guy once who represented himself completely accurately, and I was still thrown in person, because my mind had pictured him bigger, with more muscle, and he was leaner than the version I'd invented. He didn't misrepresent a thing. I did that. Another time I went out with a man much younger than me. He had one photo where he looked a little weathered, a little lived-in, and that's the one I was drawn to. In person he had a baby face. Still good looking. Just not the guy my imagination had signed off on.

They're living up to an expectation they never made. That's on us, not them. And the sooner you catch your brain doing it, the sooner you can meet the actual person in front of you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you get back into dating after years off the apps?

Expect it to feel unfamiliar, because it will. After a couple of years off, factoring another person into a life you've built on your own can feel jarring before it feels good. Go slow, notice what comes up, and treat the early awkwardness as normal rather than a sign something's wrong.

What does "not attached to outcome" mean in dating?

Not attached to outcome, or NATO, means walking into a date without pre-deciding what it has to become. Instead of auditioning someone for boyfriend or husband, you stay open to whatever the connection actually is, whether that's a friend, a fling, or something more. It takes the pressure off and lets you see the real person.

Why am I disappointed after meeting a dating app match in person?

Because your brain builds a version of them from a few photos and a bio before you ever meet. The real person can't live up to a fantasy they never agreed to. It's normal, and it usually says more about your expectations than about them.

Is midlife dating harder than dating in your 20s?

It's different. In midlife you already know your boundaries and what you need, which is an advantage. The harder part is getting comfortable voicing those things again, especially after time away from dating.

🕸️Waiting to be chosen? Download The Affair Edit.
🌱 Tired of performing? Get The Self-Worth Reset.
❤️‍🔥 Want to learn more about The Scarlet Edit? Start here.
🍒 Interested in working with me? Let’s chat.
📲 Subscribe to the show on Apple, Spotify or YouTube so you don’t miss an episode!
💌 Want more conversations like this? Sign up for the newsletter below.